Why Building a Home Feels So Stressful
Homeowners who build face constant overwhelm and looming deadlines. Their biggest fear is that the contractor will call the home "finished" and then refuse to fix any problems.
The internet feeds that fear. A quick web search turns up thousands of horror stories about indifferent contractors who ignore punch list requests.
This article explains why punch lists frustrate homeowners and builders alike. The downloadable version outlines a better way to finish the punch list. It also lists the steps to take BEFORE you sign the construction agreement.
The Anatomy of a Punch List
What a Punch List Is
At the end of construction, the builder and homeowner walk through the house together. The homeowner lists every deficiency, unfinished task, or unsatisfactory item before accepting the keys.
Punch List Items Vs. Warranty Items
Before we discuss what belongs on the list, you need to know the difference between Punch List Items and Warranty Items. Louisiana classifies structural elements as warranty items. These include the foundation, roofing, beams, load-bearing walls, and flooring.
Louisiana law holds builders responsible for these elements whether or not they appear on a punch list. Many states now follow this model. If your state has no "New Home Warranty Act," make sure your contract covers the repair of all structural items.
What Belongs on a Punch List
A homeowner's punch list mostly holds three kinds of items:
- Aesthetic flaws
- Simple oversights
- One-off items that miss the contract specifications
Most need only minor fixes, like paint and sheetrock touch-ups or flooring and tile repairs. These items rarely affect how you use the home. Crews can resolve them quickly, so they don't block your move-in or the contractor's final payment.
Why Both Sides Need One
A comprehensive list keeps everyone on the same page. It also gives the homeowner peace of mind.
Unfortunately, most contracts say nothing about how the builder will handle the punch list. Without a formal agreement, the list becomes subjective. Its outcome then depends on the integrity of the people involved.
So, why isn't there already a standardized way to deal with punchlists?
To answer this question, we must first acknowledge that neither the home builder nor the homebuyer are eager to raise the subject of punch lists. Neither builders nor homebuyers want to raise the subject. Even top-rated builders feel anxious when it comes up.
The Builder's Perspective
Builders hesitate for several reasons:
- A dishonest homeowner or subcontractor has burned them before
- They fear the homeowner has unrealistic timeline expectations
- They dread arguments over what counts as a "defect"
- They don't want blame for the homeowner's poor decisions
Some builders trust their work so much that they avoid mentioning defects before construction starts.
The Homeowner's Perspective
Most homeowners are new to the building process. Without first-hand experience, they must trust the contractor they hired. Few understand what a punch list involves, or what happens without a plan for it. Here is the other side of the coin:
- Everything about building is new, so they start at a disadvantage
- They don't want to seem inflexible, nit-picky, or demanding, so they assume problems will get solved
- They worry the builder may misunderstand their expectations, but they trust the builder to guide them
- They see subcontractors as the builder's employees, so they hold the builder responsible for quality
Why Punch List Processes Matter
Given these concerns, it's easy to see why neither side raises the topic early. But an agreement is much harder to reach after the work is done. You can't put the genie back in the bottle.
Your building contract should spell out how the builder handles punch list items. That prevents delays and unfair costs. Three issues cause most punch list disputes:
- When the builder completes the punch list
- How long the work should take
- What counts as a defect
At a minimum, both parties should agree on these points in writing. You can negotiate the exact terms, but the process must be clear.
Complete the form below to download the full article.
You will receive the download link via email within minutes!
